Showing posts with label Gear Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gear Reviews. Show all posts

Saturday, December 6, 2014

Mountain Laurel Designs Burn Backpack Review

Disclaimer: I bought this pack used with my own money and have no sponsorship or affiliation with MLD at this time.  

I picked up a Mountain Laurel Designs (MLD) Burn from a PCT friend last spring to use as a day and overnight pack over the summer since my only other pack big enough for the job was my enormous Six Moons Designs Starlight.  I got the idea from another PCT hiker I met who loves the Burn - Lint of www.linthikes.com.  He uses the Burn for PCT, CDT and AT thru-hiking, although he typically averages 30-35 miles a day which means carrying 1 to 2 days less food on a typical section than your average thru-hiker.  He also packs very light even by my standards and uses every inch of the pack.  I'd rather be able to carry a bag of potato chips (aka ghetto electrolyte tablets), but that's me.  

Speaking of inches, MLD lists the Burn as 1950 cubic inches (32 liters) of total capacity with 1500 cubic inches (25 liters) in the main body and the remainder in the extension collar, side and rear pockets.  Without pockets the pack is listed at 15 ounces,  in the large torso size with one added hip belt pocket and some shock cord mine weighed 15.2 ounces; not too shabby.  As of Fall of 2014 it lists as $175 without hip belt pockets, which I think is pricey but I am a cheap bastard. 

Packed with usual overnight gear, minus food.
Side view with 20 ounce Gatorade bottle.  Note the curve in the back panel.

Opposite side with carbon fiber tent pole.


The MLD Burn is a frameless pack that uses a drawstring closure on top.  For structure you have to rely on how you pack the bag.  In my case I like using a Gossamer Gear Nightlight to sleep on so I used that pad in the back.  Putting the Nightlight in the Burn was my first taste of just how narrow this pack is; I could barely squeeze the pad into the pack.  The pack is so narrow it squeezes the pad into a slight curve shape, which is actually more comfortable to wear than a totally flat pack. The curve sort of sets the middle of the pack in line with the depression between your back muscles. The long extension collar doesn't help fitting the pad in either, especially since it isn't tapered like you'd find on a roll top bag.  To get the pad in, you have to squeeze the edges together to make it narrower and slide it into the pack.  Not a problem once I figured that out but I found myself having to really try to stuff anything into the pack since it would get hung up on the drawstring - especially my sleeping bag.  In the big picture it adds up to an extra few minutes of annoyance a day but I'm used to having a pack that is over sized and easy to access. 


Drawstring opening is rather small.
 I found the wing belt and shoulder straps to be fine for loads in the 15 pound range, although I can't imagine fitting much more than 20 pounds in this pack since the volume is so small.  The wing belts are on the short side and stop over an inch from the end of my hip bones on my 32" waist, so much more weight than that makes the belt dig into my hips.  I didn't experience any slipping of the shoulder strap buckles at higher loads like I do with my SMD packs.  I also like the curved torso since it left the sides of my back to breath despite the initial squeeze of loading the pack.  The construction of the pack is excellent with very neat seams and a professional look.  This clearly isn't some DIY job.
My finger is on the edge of my hip bone - the wing belt stops over an inch short.

Pack bottom with slight curve on the front side making for a comfy, low sweat carry.

Here's two photo's of me in the pack.  All photos show it loaded with a typical trip (minus food) - 15 degree quilt stuffed in the bottom of the pack (no stuff sack), SMD Wild Oasis tarp, 8 ounce feathered friends puffy jacket, wind jacket, wind pants, 850mL pot and alchohol stove, long underwear, nightlight sleeping pad.  I could compress the sleeping bag and down jacket more but at this point most of the main volume of the pack is used up, leaving the extension collar and any additional compression for food.

20 ounce Gatorade Bottle in pocket.

Size Large is just big enough for my 21" torso and my T-rex arms don't touch the hip belt pocket.
In use, I had a hard time getting to my water bottles back in the side pockets of the Burn.  The side pockets are tall and hold the bottles well but they aren't slanted like other MLD packs, which makes no sense to me.  The lack of slant makes it impossible for me to put the bottle back in without removing the pack from one shoulder.  Not a big deal for a light pack, but slightly annoying.  The MLD Burn's side pockets are too narrow for my usual Gatorade bottles.  They work for 1L smart bottles, 20 ounce Gatorade bottles (shown) and slimmer 1L "disposable" water bottles but wide mouthed 1L Gatorade/Powerade bottles won't fit.  Not a deal breaker and sort of expected for a pack this small. Again, the side pocket construction is another slight irritation that doesn't mean much in the big picture but adds up.  

My pack came with one hip belt pocket, which is probably the best sized hip belt pocket I've used.  I can comfortably fit a large point and shoot camera, snack and map in there without it bulging to the point where I hit it with my arms as I walk. The pocket connects to the hip belt with two elastic loops and a clip, resulting in a very stable but easily removable pocket. It also has a waterproof zipper and no drain hole, so Ron is clearly confident in the pockets water resistance.  I did a long dayhike with the pack in blowing rain on a Presidential Ridge traverse attempt and never noticed water in the pocket. Without wind I use an umbrella which shields the pocket fairly well but I would still zip lock my camera to be safe. If I get a pack without hip belt pockets in the future, you can bet I'll buy MLD pockets.  

Love Ron's hip belt pockets, shown with RX100 camera + leather case inside.

The rear mesh pocket is excellent and will safely hold your pot, ground cloth and a small stuff sack of random crap. I added shock cord but it's unnecessary with such a tiny pack. My past experience with storing wet items to dry by hanging them shock cord has left me dropping the wet items and walking away from them without noticing, so I only use it for compression in day-pack use.  The mesh MLD uses also seems tougher than average and looks like it would hold up well to moderate bushwacking and typical thru-hiker wear and tear.  

Overall the Burn would be a great pack if you can get over the narrow opening, oddly shaped side pockets and short hip belt wing padding.  I suspect you could ask Ron at MLD to make the side pockets slanted and with longer wing padding if you order from him but I picked mine up used with the default pockets.  A roll top would be nice but I imagine that would change the template he uses for his production.  I have heard he's very accommodating on making tweaks to his products so definitely ask if you're considering this pack.  Those changes with a tapered roll top closure would make an almost perfect shoulder season day and overnight pack for me.  Instead, I'm trading the pack for heavily modified a Z-packs zero.  

Afterall, I have to do something with my free time when I'm not thru-hiking.  Might as well try out different packs!


Wednesday, July 9, 2014

Gear Review: Feathered Friends Daybreak Jacket (hooded)



This is a review of an item I plan on taking on my upcoming year of through-hiking to raise money for the Arizona Trail Association,Continental Divide Coalition and Te Araroa Trust.  Please consider donating and sharing it on Facebook!


Feathered friends is mostly known as a small Seattle based sleeping bag maker, but they also make lesser known line of goose down insulated clothing.   I took advantage of a recent sale and picked up their Daybreak hooded jacket.  Their Daybreak series are lightweight, and meant for 3 season use.  I saw a lot of similar Patagonia and Montbell down “sweaters” on the Pacific Crest Trail last year but most lacked much loft for any real warmth unlike the daybreak which has about an 3/4 of an inch of single layer loft mid-baffle.  On the PCTI carried a 20 ounce down parka from Marmot, the Ama Dablam jacket for use with my feathered friends Vireo sleeping bag instead of a much thinner down sweater.  The bag is 25 degrees on your legs and 45 on your chest and is meant for use with a down jacket. Look for a full review soon.


The Feathered Friends Vireo


I liked having the heavy Marmot jacket as piece of mind, even though it was overkill most of the time and relying on it as my only insulation caused some problems.  I didn't carry any other insulation layer other than a sleeping shirt, so when I encountered days of cold rain in Washington State I had to keep hiking to stay warm!  My breaks were limited to about ten minutes before I got cold and could only be taken at the base or partway up a climb.  I didn’t want to get either my long johns or the jacket wet since both were essential for my sleep system, which left me with only a long sleeve hiking shirt and wind jacket for continued wet, cold conditions.   

For my upcoming hikes I want something lighter with more flexibility.  Rather than a single heavy down jacket, I picked the day break and a half-zip 100 weight fleece pullover.  The daybreak weighs just over 7 ounces on my scale and the fleece pullover is 10 ounces on the nose so the total is only only a few ounces lighter than the Marmot jacket.  However, the fleece has the benefit of staying warm when wet, absorbing minimal water and drying quickly.  I can use it as a layer for hiking and since it dries fast and won’t hold much water it can still be used as sleepwear when wet, since my sleeping shirt, daybreak jacket and bag will be dry in my pack.  I recently used this combination on a Presidential Traverse attempt, including hanging out on the summit of New Hampshire’s Mount Washington in 35 degree temperatures with winds blowing over 50 miles per hour.  Based on my experience so far, I think this combination is at least as warm as, maybe slightly warmer than my Marmot jacket and a much more versatile system.  

The daybreak in action over a fleece - far left.
The Daybreak jackets construction is top notch and I have noticed no down leakage.  The hood is fitted tightly and would not work over a helmet, which is perfect for me.  Instead of a clunky drawstring, it uses elastic around your face which works great and sheds the extra grams to boot.  The bottom of the hood stops at the base of my chin, which helps retain warmth around the neck.  The sleeves have similar elastic cuffs that are tight enough to keep warm air in but not constricting – the same as the adjustment I would have made on a heavier drawstring closure and never touched again.  The bottom of the jacket does have a drawstring, which might be useful occasionally.  The fit of a medium jacket on my averagish 5 foot 8 inch frame is almost perfect.  I have short legs – my pants inseam measures 30-inches – and the jacket is long enough to cover most of the way down my hip bone, which is great and the sleeve length is great for me.  The jacket also packs into a provided stuff sack, though I rarely use stuff sacks since I prefer to use insulation layers to take up dead space in my pack.  This strategy keeps things from rattling around back there, is better for the down loft over time and takes less time to pack and unpack.

A quick note - the fit of this jacket is everything I want for the outdoors but the elastic cuffs mean it looks a fit funny on the street.  I honestly think this is a plus since a lot of outdoors clothing is being fashion-a-fied into looking better but compromising function.  At a typical gear store it can now be hard to tell what's really meant to be used in bad weather versus what's meant to be worn on the street.  I think part of the steadily rising down price trend is due to this as well, since you see 800+ fill down sweaters everywhere on people who's wallets would be better served by synthetic insulation.


The hood looks a bit funny but is much warmer than an open design.

Anyhow, the pockets on the Daybreak jacket are plenty large enough for my hands but not fleece lined, which is not a problem for me.  All the zippers feel very solid and latch easily.  The baffles seem to work well and the shell material on my 2013 jacket is made from Pertex Endurance, a water resistant breathable fabric and filled with regular 900+ fill down.  Feathered friends hasn't bought into hydrophobic coated down like most other cottage retailers and even has a post about it.  It should be noted that my sale jacket must have been the last of these since the feathered friends is now using Schoeller Nanosphere® - a new fabric that is hydrophobic!  From the manufacturers website it sounds like water and dirt should bead right off.  Sounds cool, but I think I’ll live with the older fabric and extra $100 in my pocket. 

In summary I would definitely recommend this jacket if you’re in the market for a top notch, light  weight down jacket.  They work great for camp and can extend the range of a sleep system.   If money were no object I would have probably splurged for the Helios jacket – only 3 or 4 ounces heavier but significantly warmer.  However, this jacket was on sale and will get the job done for me just fine.  

Monday, September 23, 2013

PCT - Final Thoughts

This post is just a wrap up of what I thought of the hike, what I would do differently and how I feel after.  I might edit it later as things come to me too.

When I first planned this crazy trip out, I had no idea whether or not I would succeed.  I think that uncertainty hamstringed the first half of my hike.  If I had more certainty in myself I would have  made the decision over winter and had more time to devote to preparing, gearin' up and logistics like resupplying more by mail.

As far as gear, for the most part I used what I had instead of buying new stuff and ended up with a fairly heavy base weight - around 16 pounds starting out.  That went down to around 15 when I mailed some things home.  If I had bought a new tent, new sleeping bag and lighter pack (since I wouldn't be carrying as much weight) I could have easily gotten under 10 pounds.  Then I would have carried my better camera and gotten much better photos than the point and shoot I chose to save weight.  That's probably my biggest regret, not bringing my bigger camera.  It's a valuable lesson, photographic weight is worth it on something that goes through this kind of scenery.  It probably sounds silly to not carry an extra pound but when you doubt yourself, you want every advantage you can get. I honestly had no idea how beautiful this trail would be, so hindsight is definitely 20/20. 

For planning, I would have bought a dehydrator and prepared maybe 50 or 60 dinners along the way, about half of what I ate on trail.  I'm glad I bought along the way and would still do that, but dinner was always the worst meal and seemed to lack the most variety from what you could get at a typical grocery store.  I think I would have also gone stoveless from the start but used the stove in the high sierras and maybe northern WA.  I switched from my alchohol stove to a peanut butter jar for rehydrating in Burney (~mile 1400) and really enjoyed being able to have dinner ready when I got to camp instead of one extra camp chore (really two when you have to clean the pot).  It also made resupply in town easier when you don't have to worry about buying fuel.  Out of all the ultralite things, I think going stoveless is the craziest to people who haven't hiked for weeks or months at a time, but when you just want to hike, eat and sleep it makes the most sense to me.  Sadly, my peanut butter jar was accidentally left behind in Baring and I had to make due with the plastic bags my Dad sent stuff in.  So long 28 oz Jiff jar!

You might remember my gear post here: http://theuncalculatedlife.blogspot.ca/2013/04/gear-post.html

The 15 degree marmot sleeping bag was too warm, I replaced it with a feathered friends Vireo:  

The new bag weighs like 15 ounces, is 25 degrees on your legs and 45 on your chest.  It actually worked better than I imagined, allowing me to use my down jacket like a blanket if it was a little cold, or wear it inside the bag if it was below 40 or so at night.  I stayed "warm enough" when the temperatures dropped well below freezing in the north cascades by wearing everything I had except my rain pants (they were wet). I would say that strategy makes the bag work down to about 25 degrees but you won't be happy.  The zipperless design is just like using a sleeping bag liner so no big deal there.  The only downside is the footbox is too small for my size 12 feet and I should have ordered it 6 inches longer to compensate. 

The ULA Circuit pack I started with gave me pack rash, basically irritation covering the small of my back.  I replaced it with a Six Moon Designs Starlite pack:




It's entirely frameless but uses your sleeping pad as a frame and padding for the back of the pack in a little zippered pocket.  The pack works well but was way too big for the volume of stuff I was carrying.  The extra space might have been nice for a bear can in the Sierra's but it really was just too big a pack for me with all my crazy minimalism.  No pack rash and it weighs a full pound less than the ULA pack so big wins there though.  I found it carried better if I didn't compress my down sleeping bag and down jacket.  The shoulder strap system is a little wonky but works really well. 

I also saved about half a pound by switching to a Gossamer Gear Nightlite sleeping pad.  It's ridiculously light and more comfortable than the z-lite had earlier and which got pretty compressed by 1,400 miles of continuous use.  I liked sleeping on the flat side but wish it was an inch wider so my arms would fit a bit more than barely.   I found gossamer gear thinlite pad in a hiker box back at Ziggy and the Bears which worked great as a sit pad and doubled over for my feet.

Those changes and only carrying one set of sleeping clothes, one set of hiking clothes and up to 3 pairs of socks took a big chunk out of my base weight.  In hindsight, I should have used these instead:

Tent: Z-packs Hexamid solo plus - this would have saved 3/4 of a pound over my tarptent.
Pack: Z-packs Zero backpack - not the one pictured, I would have added a lot of extra stuff (side and rear pockets, load lifters, hip belt, ice axe loops, etc.) but the total would be around 8 or 9 ounces, saving almost a full pound over the six moons starlite.  Those two changes would have easily covered the extra weight of my larger camera.  Oh well, maybe next year?



Mentally, I thought after being in the woods for four and a half months would make me miss walking through the wilderness but I actually feel pretty good back in civilization.  I always looked forward to towns and eating real food so that probably helps.  The biggest difference to me is social.  On most of the PCT (aside from the sierra and WA), almost every hiker you see is a through hiker.  You automatically have a 2600 mile journey in common and can bond instantly over it.  You share so many values to make that kind of commitment that it's almost like a club.  Real life is full of strangers that you'll probably never talk to, have nothing in common about and don't really care about. With this in mind, I probably would have started at kick-off with most of the other hikers.  I could have taken the beginning slower, and probably met more people instead of passing by them at a faster pace. I do notice that I feel overwhelmed more easily when surrounded by a lot of people and noise, like at the hostel I'm staying at in Vancouver.  I really want to just walk away and read a book or watch a movie somewhere quiet.

Physically, my feet are sore every time I sit down for more than half an hour and they really hurt after sleeping until I walk around for a minute or two.  My legs feel sort of gelatinous but seem to work ok, no knee or joint pain.  I haven't had blisters for over 2,000 miles and my IT band issues seemed to disappear after hiking Mount Whitney but I have no idea why.  I'm hungry all the time and trying to eat a lot of veggies to make up for the crap food I ate on trail. I started the trail at 176 pounds and the last weigh in was somewhere around 165 pounds a few hundred miles from the finish.  I think I lost all the weight in SoCal, then started packing almost 2.5 pounds of food per day and things leveled off.  I may have actually gained weigh in Oregon.  Must have been the beer. 

Don't take this to mean I regret the hike, it's been the most amazing thing I've ever done.  I have a lot more self confidence after completing what I thought might have been an impossible task five months ago.  I've also learned a lot about what I'm capable of pushing myself through.  Some day I'll probably hike the PCT again, or at least a few chunks of it.  Until then I plan on exploring Vancouver a bit more, visiting a friend in Seattle and a few in Portland, then heading out to Moab to see some canyons in October with Sir Poppins, the guy I met early on in Washington.  Hopefully I can job hunt at the same time and do some traveling instead of twiddling my thumbs in my parents basement. 

Real life is still a ways off and I'll keep posting here and there. 


Monday, April 22, 2013

Stove post!

I've had some questions about my stove, so I thought I would post a few pictures.

It's two soda cans cut and jammed together with an inner sleeve that creates a kind of gasification chamber between the outside soda can wall and the sleeve.  The 16 holes allow the hot alcohol gas from the chamber to be vented and burned. I actually forgot my lighter at home and had to use my "back up" sparker to light it.  The trick is to cup your hand over the top so the alcohol vapors can accumulate enough to be lit by sparks instead of a lighter.

 Here you can see the JB weld sealing the upper part of the chamber, it also seals the sleeve.  I cut two tiny triangles out of the bottom of the sleeve to allow alcohol into the chamber through the bottom. 

Home made wire mesh pot stand and disposable aluminum baking sheet wind screen complete the menagerie. 

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Gear post!

You can't go on a through hike and not write a few thousand words about gear.  It just isn't possible.

This will be my still evolving gear post.  My spreadsheet of items and weights and all that fun stuff is located here.  Below I will briefly go through my choices.  First the "big three" weighing in at a hair under 7 pounds.


Pack:


ULA Circuit
At 2 lbs 7 ounces the circuit is on the lightweight side of traditional backpacks and the heavy side of ultralight backpacks.  For two or three day treks I would love a nice 10 ounce, frameless cuben fiber pack but not when I have to carry 6 days of food or two gallons of water.  This pack has wide shoulder straps, a wide hip belt and good load support without relying on a flimsy foam pad.  I've done two winter overnights in the white mountains here in New Hampshire with it and the variety of shoulder strap, load lifter, chest strap and hip belt adjustments make rearranging the weight on your back easy and variable enough to keep the pack comfortable.  The only real negative to me is a lack of additional pockets, although the large mesh pocket in back is nice.  This is also one of the few pieces of gear I bought specifically for this hike. 

Sleeping bag:


Marmot Helium 15 degree bag
 850 fill down with DWR coating makes for a comfy bag.  I got this on a steep discount last summer and have been very happy with it.  I slept warm in wool long underwear with a fleece hat at 24 degrees the other weekend.  Adding my down jacket would be another layer of warmth if needed.  There are ultralight "quilts" or psuedo-mummy bags with no insulation on the bottom which shave 6-10 ounces but it isn't worth the cost to me.  This is the most expensive piece of gear to replace so for the PCT I'm using what I have.  I'll be using this with a 3/4 length thermarest z-lite foam pad.  I like the quick setup time of foam instead of inflatable and it makes an easy yoga-mat/sit pad double (not possible with an inflatable).  I used to abhor 3/4 length pads until someone pointed out you can sleep with your feet on your empty backpack.

Tent:


Tarptent Notch
Not a tarp but not a free standing tent either.  It can use either hiking poles or tent poles or sticks for support along with 4 aluminum stakes.  1 lb 10 ounces with the optional bug net liner (not used in SoCal) makes it damn light for a single person tent.  I purchased mine about a year ago when I was in love with hiking poles and picked up the optional tent poles for bike touring.  Since then I no longer use hiking poles most* of the time but it still makes for a great tent.  There is a setup learning curve (which I'm about midway up) to getting a taunt pitch 100% of the time but it works and seems sturdy enough.  What nice is the removable interior which I won't need for SoCal and will save me 8 ounces. 

*they're great for insanely rocky downhills and stream crossings but that's about it.

Stove/Cook system:

Sadly my only DIY gear. This has been the latest piece of gear to evolve.  I originally planned to use a trianga mini but have found it to be an inefficient, overweight system.  Instead I've made a soda can stove similar to the instructions here but using JB Weld (a type of epoxy) to seal the gassification chamber up.  It warms up much faster than a penny can stove, doesn't need priming and is more efficient than a cat can stove.  I plan on taking up to 8 ounces of denatured alcohol or HEET (fuel additive found at most gas stations along the PCT) at a time with me which should yield about 10 to 12 meals.  See my stove post here!

Camp Jacket: 


Marmot Ama Dablam down jacket (discontinued)
Like the tent and sleeping bag, puffy down jackets are expensive and I already own this one so no added cost.  It's definitely heavy for a puffy at 18 ounces (Montbell and others make similar jackets in the 8-12 ounce range) but whatever.  I don't want to replace what I already have and it will likely be trashed by the end of the trail so I can look at new fancier lighter jackets then.  Some nice features include the DWR coating, high collar in front of your mouth and the draw string closures.  I just washed mine with special down soap and it is back to its original puffiness. This with my winter shell have kept me toasty atop many 10-20 degree 50 mph winter summits in the white mountains.  This also doubles as my pillow when stuffed into its internal pocket-stuff sack.  It will spend most of its time un-stuffed taking up extra room in my pack.

Wind Jacket 


This jacket weighs almost nothing! Four ounces! Four!  Amazing.  Also the only piece of patagucchi I'm taking, mainly because their stuff is expensive and rarely on sale. Wind jackets are also pretty unusual here in the Northeast but come highly recommended for the vast open stretches out west.  I will not be taking a rain jacket until I hit WA so this will be my rain shell as well. 

Sun/Rain Protection

Golite Chrome Dome
As an east coaster who spends 95% of a hike under tree cover it sounds completely ridiculous to me as well.  Apparently out west they don't have the wealth of canopy we enjoy for free sun protection and hiking umbrellas have almost reached legitimacy so I may not be laughed off the trail. Golite makes an 8 ounce reflective umbrella which is supposedly strong and I figured out how to attach it to my pack so I don't have to hold it!  This will be perfect for the desert sun and the light rain of OR and WA.  Not sure about the Sierras.

Now for the electronics!
My camera, my kindle and my SPOT gps messenger.  The SPOT is to keep my parents from worrying and let other people know where I am/live vicariously.  The kindle has free 3G wireless so I can check the water report for updates and send quick emails.  The internet is very very slow so you have to be patient but the battery will last about 3 weeks and uses the same charger as my dumb phone.


Well, that about wraps up the most interesting gear.  For more details see my gear spreadsheet or ask questions below!